I recently finished the 2004 book by Thomas Frank,
What's the Matter With Kansas?, and figured I'd share with you my thoughts on the subject.
My initial thoughts were of disappointment - he spent most of the book merely explaining what it was that bothered him about Kansas, without explaining why these changes from his childhood have occurred. But it got better toward the end.
To summarize, he claims that conservatism stole class-consciousness for their use because mass media and mass culture had de-emphasized economics thus allowed the Right to do the same even as they use the rhetoric of left-wing populism from the turn of the century. As America drew itself to this rhetoric as it had before, in an appeal to an ideal, foregone past, liberals also abandoned the economic to chase socially liberal voters. And this only helped the cultural dynamic the Right uses to bring in blue-collar voters by fueling the Backlash. But even as they rant against Hollywood's social values, the Right is doing everything it can to give Hollywood a tax cut. And Hollywood's culture is only getting more disgusting because disgusting is more popular; no one ever stopped to think about ways to change Hollywood.
The mood is, vote for another Republican, hope for the best. But even as the conservative politicians rail against rare incidents like gay marriage or flag burning while they campaign, once in office all those concerns are swept aside for focus on promoting outsourcing and giving tax cuts to billionaires. And I agree with this - in the 30 years since Roe v. Wade, how many times have Republicans actually sought to do something about this outside of making it an election issue?
So, Kansas and America gets angry about the collapse of their small towns, and Republicans channel that anger toward electing the very people who help encourage that collapse. By focusing anger on the politics of culture, but doing nothing about it, Republicans are fueling a never-ending sense of victimhood.
It's a very convoluted situation, made all the more distressing, in Mr. Frank's opinion, by the willing surrender by Democrats of economic liberalism. Democrats, by chasing socially liberal voters, are in essence enabling their own demise by allowing working class America to focus on social issues without regard to their own material interests.
So think about this next time Ann Coulter is on television. Ann is railing against a kiss by Madonna and Britney Spears even as she fights ever harder to elect Republicans who will give Madonna and Britney a tax cut.
Who really cares about our culture when they reward the people they supposedly despise?